From the architect. A low-impact intervention Located in the Plateau Mont-Royal, a centennial home welcomes a family who wish to breathe new life into their space and establish a new dialogue with its surrounding environment. With a vision to respect the home’s original character and preserve the large poplar rooted in the backyard, Microclimat designed a low-impact intervention for an addition that would occupy a small portion of the garden. This new space would blossom from the home through two new large openings in the existing brick wall.
The expanded architecture—an intermediate area between the yard and the living quarters—offers a newfound flow of space and light in the home without compromising intimacy. Through the fluid transition resides a sharp contrast between the modern addition and the home’s original design from 1885, one that is further accentuated by the addition of a light steel staircase that serves as a filter between the interior and exterior spaces.
3D
This staircase connects the spaces and allows a complete reorganization of the home’s original interior design, all while representing the verticality of the tree, thus reinforcing the relationship between the home and its roots. Two sunrooms located near the new wooden windows of the refurbished space offer a comfortable reading space near the yard, providing the family with the opportunity to enjoy the surrounding environment year round.
A cantilevered mezzanine Perched on the peak of the new space, the mezzanine is home to the master bedroom, with direct access to a new rooftop terrace. This mezzanine is cantilevered on both sides of the home and yard, floating quite literally over the neighbouring homes and minimizing the modifications made to the original structure.
The Hôtel-de-Ville residence shows the potential of considered architectural interventions to rethink the purpose of a space by establishing a new connection to its surroundings, in this case the shared roots between a centennial home and a poplar tree.
Architecture Microclimat Founded in 2013, Microclimat is a budding firm whose work ethos is grounded in the principle that architecture and the environment in which it evolves, are perpetually feeding one another. via v2com
Speaking on the subject of Louis Kahn, who died the same year Ingels was born, in 1974, he remarked, “I wouldn’t say that my work is linear of Louis’ but I think that he rediscovered symbolism and designed super-functional architecture that’s been lost and has been re-created by pragmatism.” This fits into Ingels’ own views on his practice, Bjarke Ingels Group (BIG), which he described as “pragmatic utopianism,” asserting a belief that architecture is “the art and science of turning fiction into fact.”
Remarking on BIG’s first project in Philadelphia, 1200 Intrepid, Ingels stated, “When we were coming up with the design, there was a clear place taking form already—the Navy Yard master plan was already in place. We thought we should inherit as much from the park, designed by Field Operations, as much as possible. We thought the circular park would be sort of a strong gesture and influence the building, so we designed the road in front of the building to curve with it. The white prefabricated concrete panels are sort of like the bracelets of a watch, and they tilt so that it creates a graceful, organic space and inviting cave like canopy.”
1200 Intrepid, Philadelphia Navy Yard. Image Courtesy of Bjarke Ingels Group
From the architect. Museum of Apoxyomenos is a building specifically converted to house one single exhibit: The Athlete of Croatia, a famous 192 cm high bronze sculpture made most likely in 2nd or 1st century BC in a Greek foundry. The sculpture was raised from the sea in the vicinity of the island Lošinj in Northern Adriatic in 1999. Statue is one of few remaining Greek bronze sculptures from Hellenistic period and one of the best preserved.
Discussion where to display the sculpture has involved different cities, but at the end the choice fell on city of Mali Lošinj. This decision was in line with the Croatian cultural policy from the 1990’s, favoring construction of museums in smaller communities. Museums have demonstrated capacity to generate social interaction and become true public spaces, so it made perfect sense to display the sculpture right next to the place it was discovered.
Two elements of this narrative were important for the architectural approach. The first one was that the sculpture found in the sea had actually no connection with the surrounding and it clearly belonged to a very different time and place.
The second one was a curious decision not to build a new building for it, but to use the interior of an existing house instead. Conditions from the Conservation Department even prohibited any intervention on the façade, demanding it to be restored in the original shape. It seemed odd that one of the most magnificent finds from Hellenistic period had to be displayed inside a carefully restored not-so-significant building.
For that reason museum was conceived as a completely independent metal casing, inserted inside the perimeter walls of the existing building. Display in the interior of a building also implied a more intimate presentation of the sculpture.
The inserted element is an exhibition device, dividing the area in 3 different spaces: exhibition space, residual space (service space) and public space.
Exhibition space is created froma predetermined exhibition concept, defining enclosed area of the museum. The outer shape of it is a wrap-up of these spaces.
Third is the public space. Ground floor is conceived as a covered extension of the waterfront promenade, open for different uses, from exhibitions to various events.
Section
Exhibition space, leading gradually to the sculpture, was conceived as a path.
Dynamics of the waterfront, particularly during the summer months, are not creating the most appropriate background for the museum. Waterfront is a vibrant public space, full with attractions, that are at the same time distractions.
The competition brief mentioned purification and decontamination of visitors in technical description of air-conditioning and ventilation requirements. It became apparent that the location required a sort of emotional purification as well, to prepare the visitors for the encounter with the sculpture.
One of most common ritual forms of purification is a procession. Visitor is led, through a succession of the spaces and gradually prepared for the contact. Architectural space is seen as a “architectural promenade”, as Corbusier used to call it, as a personal journey through space. Sequence of different spaces creates enough distance between the sculpture and the street but it also creates a sense of anticipation and discomfort, liberating the senses for the encounter.
Journey starts with an escalator, that brings group in the first room with exhibition displays about the sculpture and the find. The second room is a soft room covered with thick carpet, where the visitors watch the movies. From there a narrow staircase leads to a periscope room, where one sees the sculpture from below, and in enlarged details on the screen. The path continues in the olive-tree cladded corridor with displays exhibiting organic material found in the sculpture. From there the group finally enters the exhibition room with the sculpture. Journey ends in the last room in the attic, mirroring the view of the bay.
Sunlight has proven to be an excellent formgiver, with which architecture can create dynamic environments. The lighting design pioneer William M.C. Lam (1924-2012) emphasized in his book “Sunlighting as Formgiver” that the consideration of daylight is about much more than energy efficiency. Architects have now found numerous ways of implementing sunlight and the questions arises whether a coherent daylight typology could be a valuable target during the design process. However, many daylight analyses focus mainly on energy consumption.
Siobhan Rockcastle and Marilyne Andersen, though, have developed a thrilling qualitative approach at EPFL in Lausanne. Their interest was driven by the spatial and temporal diversity of daylight, introducing a matrix with 10 shades of daylight.
Observing daylight, we encounter the possibility of two extremes: direct sunlight, with clear blue skies and the diffuse cloudy sky as a counterpoint. They both lead to very different feelings and associations. Direct sunlight creates an intense modelling with harsh shadows and its direction during the course of the day has a major impact. Hence, our environment seems to be very diverse with the duality of light and shadow. Simultaneously the brightness of the blue sky has a very activating effect on us – which is why many people spend their holidays at destinations that guarantee sunshine in order to seek happiness.
But when clouds appear and fill the sky, the brightness decreases significantly and we lose the modelling due to the lack of clear shadows. Subsequently we encounter a dimmed situation of uniformity and calm. Such conditions settle our mind because we are not stimulated by diverse and dynamic surroundings.
Within the EPFL research study Siobhan Rockcastle and Marilyne Andersen analysed numerous examples of contemporary architecture with regard to the spatial and temporal variability of daylight. Their conclusion led finally to a typological categorization with 10 categories ranging from direct exaggerated patterns to indirect and diffuse spaces. In this way an analogy occurs to the two extreme weather situations of direct sunlight and cloudy sky. For a brief overview, here we will explore the three major groups of high contrast, medium and low contrast rooms.
A dramatic and even exaggerated daylight pattern design emerges with top- and side-lit spaces like Norman Foster‘s Kogod courtyard at the Smithsonian Institution, the Seattle Central Library by OMA or the Zollverein School by SANAA. The distinct façade structures create intense shadow patterns which move constantly during the day. The large, clear glass elements in the façade create high brightness levels that seem almost as bright as outside. When the façade openings are smaller, a screen façade leads to similar effects but with a finer pattern design. The Louvre Abu Dhabi by Ateliers Jean Nouvel is an excellent example of a screen technique with the characteristic Arabic Mashrabiya.
The medium contrast category uses partially or selectively direct light in combination with indirect daylight. These spaces avoid both extreme contrasts over time and a dull atmosphere. Mies van der Rohe worked with large side-lit glass panes for his Farnsworth House with minimal obstructions in the forms of additions like louvers. The changes over the day are clearly visible, but they stay away from striking shadow patterns. Peter Zumthor’s Therme Vals represents a remarkable compromise of selectively direct light. The powerful grazing light effect contributes a characteristic contrast but the pattern does not change that much during the day like at the Seattle Central Library. Daniel Libeskind’s Imperial War Museum is a similar example of playing with lines of daylight in the interior space to build up a certain mood.
The third category comprises modes of indirect diffuse lighting and thereby eliminates intense contrasts and changes over time. Steven Holl’s daylight softly elevates the Chapel of St. Ignatius into a sacred space with several bottle-shaped tubes dispersing the light. A more deliberate solution regarding indirect lighting has emerged with buildings where the entire roof consists of daylight scoop grids against direct sunlight, such as in Renzo Piano’s High Museum in Atlanta. However, the ultimate example of a diffuse atmosphere derives from projects like Shigeru Ban’s Naked House. Here the diffuse walls stretch from ground to ceiling and grant the feeling of floating in a cloud. Due to the large luminous vertical surfaces hardly any shadow is left for modelling.
The value of the daylight typology by Siobhan Rockcastle and Marilyne Andersen with their two factors of contrast and dynamic impact lies in emphasizing daylight as a spatial quality beyond energy-driven metrics. This approach could evolve into a useful classification to reflect the qualities of daylight in daily design work. The three main groups, ranging from direct exaggerated to indirect and diffuse, enable a quick overview for the concept stage, whereas the 10 categories allow a more differentiated evaluation for the advanced design process. Additional simulations with simplified spatial models even open a path to generate year-round renderings in order to study the variability over time in more detail. Thereby, we would speak less about average values but more about the dynamic composition of light and shadow in the space.
Light matters, a monthly column on light and space, is written by Thomas Schielke. Based in Germany, he is fascinated by architectural lighting and works for the lighting company ERCO. He has published numerous articles and co-authored the books “Light Perspectives” and “SuperLux”. For more information check www.arclighting.de or follow him @arcspaces.